How Apparel Brands Can Scale Circularity: 5 Lessons on Textile Recovery, Resale and EPR

Insights from Supercircle, GUESS?, Darn It! and Recover at Sourcing Journal's 2026 Fall Summit
Key takeaways
- Scaling circularity starts with product-level data: knowing what each item is, what it's made of and where it should go next.
- Takeback programs generate recovery data that can inform sourcing, design and material decisions.
- Recycling isn't always the highest-value outcome. Repair, resale and donation often recover more.
- Supercircle estimates a $170 billion opportunity to recover value from retail apparel through a connected aftermarket.
- Textile EPR laws like California's SB 707 should strengthen the existing recovery ecosystem, not just add cost.
Circularity is the practice of keeping products and materials in use through resale, repair, takeback and recycling. Each pathway works on its own. Scaled together as one connected system, they turn textile waste into revenue.
That was the core message of The State of Circular Business: Circularity at Scale, a panel at Sourcing Journal's 2026 Fall Summit. Supercircle Co-Founder and CEO Chloe Songer joined Courtney Culbreath, Associate Director of Corporate Social Responsibility - ESG at GUESS?, Jeff Glassman, CEO of Darn It! and Enes Adak, Co-CEO at Recover, to discuss the infrastructure, technology and economics behind circularity at scale.
Supercircle is a circular retail infrastructure company. We help brands identify, sort and route products to the resale, repair, donation and recycling partners where they hold the most value.
Here are five lessons from the discussion.
1. What do brands need to scale circularity?
Brands need product-level intelligence: data on what each item is, what it's made of, what it's worth in the aftermarket and which recovery pathways fit it.
Once a product leaves its original supply chain, that visibility usually disappears. Without it, brands can't tell a resellable jacket from a recycling-grade one, so value is lost at the first sort.
“We see circularity as a large unstructured-data problem.”
The hard part is identifying products at scale and connecting each one to the right partner in a fragmented downstream network. That's the gap Supercircle fills: one system that identifies, sorts and routes products to their best next life, with visibility into where every item ends up.
2. How do takeback programs create useful data?
Every recovered product tells a brand something about what happens after the first sale. Aggregated, that becomes a feedback loop into sourcing and design.
The GUESS? online takeback program, powered by Supercircle, lets consumers anywhere in the U.S. return garments from any brand. Our partner Homeboy Threads uses Supercircle’s sortation technology to process the items, generating data on product categories, material composition and participation.
"It lets us know what types of materials are being recycled the most." - Courtney Culbreath, Associate Director of Corporate Social Responsibility & ESG, GUESS?
For GUESS?, that data now informs its approach to circular design. As recovery programs grow, the same intelligence can shape how future products are designed, made and managed.
3. Is recycling always the best outcome for used clothing?
No. The best outcome is whichever pathway keeps the most value in a product, based on its condition, composition and likely next use.
- Repair: Products with quality defects can be fixed and sold again. Commercial repair specialists like Darn It! recover defective inventory before it ever reaches consumers.
- Resale: Items in good condition can be resold at full or near-full value.
- Donation: Wearable items with low resale value can serve communities in need.
- Recycling: Items at the end of their wearable life can become new fiber. Recyclers like Recover turn suitable textiles back into usable cotton fiber.
Recycling isn't one-size-fits-all either. As Recover's Enes Adak explained, feedstock suitability depends on the intended end use. Fiber blends, trims and contaminants all affect recycled fiber quality and the economics of recovery.
That's why routing matters. Sending each product to the outcome that fits it is what makes a recovery system pay off.
4. Can textile recovery generate revenue?
Yes. Textile recovery has long been treated as a waste-management cost, but recovered products hold significant unrealized value. Supercircle estimates a $170 billion opportunity in retail apparel.
Capturing it takes scale: aggregating products across brands, identifying them at the unit level and connecting them to specialized downstream partners. Scale is what makes recovery efficient enough to be profitable.
"It's not just a cost or a tax over time, but actually a way to generate additional revenue back into the business." - Chloe Songer
The materials side is shifting too. Recover already produces certain recycled cotton materials at or below the cost of virgin alternatives [cite source]. Circular supply chains can now compete on price, not just sustainability.
5. What is California SB 707, and how should textile EPR work?
California's SB 707 is a textile extended producer responsibility (EPR) law. EPR makes brands responsible for managing the products they put on the market at end of life.
We've been involved in shaping SB 707, and we've advocated for policy that strengthens the existing recovery ecosystem. Good EPR should let private-sector partners participate and grow, not simply shift the bill for textile waste.
“We want this to be legislation that enables an ecosystem of supply chain partners to flourish.”
Done poorly, EPR becomes another cost passed through the supply chain to consumers. Done well, it funds systems that make recovery accessible, scalable and profitable, so preserving product value becomes the better business decision.
The next phase of circularity
The brands that win the next phase will treat every returned garment as data and inventory, not waste. The infrastructure to do that at scale exists today.
Launching a takeback program or preparing for textile EPR? Talk to Supercircle about turning recovered products into revenue.


